[Home] [Cemetery page] [Torrey cemetery page] [Torrey Index] [General Index]


Yates County Cemetery Project
Part III: Cemeteries in the town of Torrey


 

Mount Pleasant Cemetery: Notes

Mount Pleasant Cemetery Mount Pleasant Cemetery is the burial ground associated with the old Presbyterian Church that once stood next to it. The church itself has vanished completely; the building ceased being used as such once the congregation built a new church in Dresden in 1834.

The cemetery is now maintained by the town, but was neglected for so long that it presents a real challenge to the reader.

Unfortunately, a great many of the stones are broken into several pieces. Also, to make mowing easier many of the footstones have been moved from their original sites and laid flat in large groups. They are well preserved but have lost all association with their headstones. Initialed footstones that could not be matched with headstones are noted in the listings. Luckily there were several fairly reliable older readings, and all the known ones were collated to help decipher the more obscure names.

 

Mount Pleasant Cemetery: Burials


--ow? ---- m Daughter of John & Ann --ow? [stone very worn]
Ansley Mary [Mead] 1852 [ ] B1821 Mar 3; wife of William Ansley & daughter of Joshua & Phebe Mead [broken stone] [Mead plot]
Armstrong Alexander # 1820 B1798; son of George & Elizabeth Armstrong [slate stone, inscription gone, next to Elizabeth Armstrong; could be his] [Armstrong plot]
Armstrong Elizabeth [1831 Aug 17] [D ae 75] wife of George Armstrong [stone partially buried] [Armstrong plot]
Badgley Henry 1831 Oct 27 D ae 30
Barnes Caroline 1834 Aug 26 D ae 16; daughter of Joseph & Mary Barnes [Barnes plot]
Barnes James 1837 Aug 17 D ae 52; son of John & Hannah Barnes [Barnes plot]
Barnes John 1839 Aug 9 D ae 94/5/4 [Barnes plot]
Barnes Joseph 1858 B1776 [Barnes plot]
Barnes Mary 1837 Mar 24 D ae 56/1/5; wife of Joseph Barnes [Barnes plot]
Barnes Mercy # 1850 Apr D ae 6 in Benton [mortality schedule]
Barnes William 1823 Jul 18 D ae 10/7/7; only son of Joseph & Mary Barnes [Barnes plot]
Barnes William 1849 Jun 16 D ae 81 [Barnes plot]
Bates Bethyar 1841 Apr 18 D ae 75/3/20; wife of William Bates
Bates William 1852 Jan 5 B1761 Dec 15; died age 90/21 days; Revolutionary War: 3rd Massachusetts Militia
Beeden Elizabeth Ann 1839 Aug 5 D ae 2/3/24; daughter of Thomas & Elizabeth Beeden [Barnes plot]
Belt Edatha 1841 Nov 11 D ae 73 [Belt plot]
Belt John, Rev. 1882 Apr 16 D ae 73 [Belt plot]
Belt Lucy 1879 Jul 7 [B1808] [broken stone] [Belt plot]
Belt William 1854 Dec 1 D ae 80/10/26 [Belt plot]
Belt William 1863 Mar 1 B1844 Sep 17; son of John & Lucy Belt [Belt plot]
Brown Dudley 1847 Jun 28 D ae 66/6/5 [Brown plot]
Brown Hannah 1864 Jan 1 D ae 79/2/2; wife of Dudley Brown [Brown plot]
Brown Hiram B 1862 Jan 4 D ae 28/2 days [Brown plot]
Brush Mary Bush 1833 D ae ?/9; wife of Charles Brush & daughter of Rynard & Elizabeth Bush [Rynard Bush plot]
Burton Mary 1881 Mar 10 D ae 88; wife of John Burton
Burton William 1827 Jan 7 Infant of John & Mary Burton; died age 9 months & 15 days [adjacent to Mary Burton]
Bush Andrew 1830 Sep 12 D ae 8 months and 12 days; son of Henry L. & Margaret Bush [Henry Bush plot]
Bush Barnard 1870 Jul 26 D ae 80/2/19 [son of Lodowick & Magdaline Bush] [Lodowick Bush plot]
Bush Elizabeth 1858 Sep 13 D ae 85/9/11; wife of Rynard Bush [Rynard Bush plot]
B[ush] E[lizabeth] A[ckerman] [1836 Nov 12] [D ae 26/7/1] wife of Andrew Bush [broken stone; footstone]
Bush Finlay A. 1839 Aug 26 D ae 1/4/12; son of David & Rachel Bush [Lodowick Bush plot]
Bush Harriet M. 1839 Aug 21 D Ae 2/7/13; daughter of David & Rachel Bush [Lodowick Bush plot]
Bush Lodowick 1839 Sep 15 D ae 76/8/27 [Lodowick Bush plot]
Bush Magdaline [Visshee] 1839 Oct 19 [D ae 6]8; wife of Lodowick Bush[broken stone] [Lodowick Bush plot]
Bush Mary [Forshee] 1857 Mar 23 D ae 65/8/6; wife of Barnard Bush [Lodowick Bush plot]
Bush Rynard 1848 Aug 6 D ae 77/11/20 [Rynard Bush plot]
Bush Stephen 1827 Nov 30 D ae 50 days; son of Henry L. & Margaret Bush [Henry Bush plot]
Bush William 1835 Jul 30 D ae 8 months and 24 days; son of Henry L. & Margaret Bush [Henry Bush plot]
Chapman Aaron E. 1844 Mar 27 D ae 29/19 days; son of Heman & Lovina Chapman [Chapman plot]
Chapman Andrew F. # 1909 Oct 10 D ae 89/4/16 in Penn Yan; son of Heman & Lovina Swarthout Chapman [town record]
Chapman George m "Little George" [Chapman plot]
Chapman George 1861 Oct 17 D ae 34/9/12 [Chapman plot]
Chapman Heman 1854 Mar 17 B1794 May 3 [Chapman plot]
Chapman Lovina C. 1875 May 22 B1794 Mar 9; wife of Heman Chapman [Chapman plot]
Chapman Samuel A. 1832 Mar 31 D ae 5 months and 6 days; son of Samuel S. & Sarah Chapman [Armstrong plot]
Clary Stalham, Rev. 1831 Nov 25 D ae 50
Cleveland George # 1874 Dec 13 D ae 69 in Benton [mortality schedule]
Coe Martha 1846 Oct 14 D ae 79/8/15; wife of Matthew Coe
Coe Mathew 1838 Dec 12 B1757 Oct 15, died age 81/1/27; Revolutionary War: 2nd NY Militia
Cr[am]er Deborah 1861 Jan 17 D ae 52/8/5 [servant to James M. Pow] [broken stone]
Denniston H[annah Bush] [1859] [B1804; wife of David Denniston & daughter of Lodowick &] Magdaline [Bush] [broken stone & footstone] [Lodowick Bush plot]
Deyo Mary E. 1840 Aug 11 D ae 1/4/1; daughter of Ezekiel & Jane Deyo
Dougherty Anthony 1829 May 1 Dae 37/8
Downey Elizabeth 1878 Jan 16 D ae 60/5 [Downey plot]
Downey Rachel 1832 Dec 13 D ae 55/5; wife of Robert Downey [Downey plot]
Downey Robert 1833 Oct 27 D ae 67/8/9 [Downey plot]
Eddy Catharine J. 1841 Feb 3 D ae 6 months; daughter of Rev. A. & C. H. Eddy [same stone as Jane J. Eddy]
Eddy Jane J. 1842 Aug 23 D ae 9 months; daughter of Rev. A. & C. H. Eddy
Gage Arnold C. # 1892 May 6 D ae 74; son of Jesse T. & Mary Gage [town record]
Garrison Elizabeth Higgins 1862 Jan 8 B1778 Sep 29; wife of Samuel Garrison [Garrison plot]
Garrison James 1840 Jun 16 D ae 30/7/21 [Garrison plot]
Garrison Samuel 1855 Jun 30 B1775 Oct 23 [Garrison plot]
Garrison Sarah Smith 1848 Jan 15 B1749 Mar 11; wife of Rev. Reuben Garrison [Garrison plot]
[Gates] Mary [Trimmer] 1861 Mar 15? D ae 68?; wife of William [Gates & daughter of Anthony & Sarah Howard Trimmer] [stone very worn]
Gaylord Amanda F. [1833 Apr 24] [B1829] daughter of Benjamin & Rachel Gaylord [stone buried in tree] [John Gaylord plot; also recorded on the Gaylord monument in Bellona Cemetery, Benton]
Gaylord Amos 1872 Nov 7 D ae 85/2/26 at Pontiac Michigan; born at Bristol, Hartford Co., Conn. [Amos Gaylord plot]
Gaylord Charlotte 1844 May 4 B1762 Feb 15; wife of John Gaylord [John Gaylord plot]
Gaylord Emily 1828 Sep 16 D ae 10 months & 27 days; daughter of Benjamin & Rachel Gaylord [John Gaylord plot; also recorded on the Gaylord monument in Bellona Cemetery, Benton]
Gaylord Sally [P.] 1859 Sep 15 D ae 64/2/22; wife of Amos Gaylord [Amos Gaylord plot]
Gaylord Sarah Adeline 1849 Oct 28 D ae 20/1/16; only daughter of Amos & Sarah Gaylord [Amos Gaylord plot]
Goundry ---- 1847 Oct 11 D ae 20/1 [broken stone] [Goundry plot]
Goundry Charles H. 1843 Sep 5 D ae 7 months & 8 days; son of Caleb & Electra Goundry [Goundry plot]
Goundry George 1837 Apr 18 D ae 25/5/7; son of Wm & Margaret Goundry [Goundry plot]
Goundry Margaret 1869 --- -0 D ae 78/10/1 [wife of William Goundry] [broken stone] [Goundry plot]
Goundry Margaret # 1839 B1839; daughter of George & Margaret Goundry
Goundry Margaret J. 1839 Aug 10 D ae 3/3/29; daughter of Caleb & Electa Goundry [Goundry plot]
Goundry Nancy G. 1821 Dec 9 D ae 10 & 28 days; daughter of Wm & Margaret Goundry [Goundry plot]
Goundry Wellington 1831 Jun 8 D ae 10 months & 20 days; son of Wm & Margaret Goundry [Goundry plot]
Goundry William 1846 Dec 17 D ae 62/5 [Goundry plot]
Gregory Jane M. Bell 1862 Jun 3 B1820 Oct 24; wife of Wyllys Gregory
Haight Abbey 1812 Feb 28 D ae 51/3/16; wife of Stephen Haight
Haight Stephen 1812 Dec 22 B1760 May 8; Revolutionary War: Lieut., Graham's Regt., NY Militia
Hall George O. 1840 Dec 30 D ae 9 months 10 days; son of William & Elizabeth Hall [Hall plot]
Hall Jonathan 1840 Feb 9 D ae 76 [Hall plot]
Hall Jonathan A. 1852 May 20 B1796 Jan 2 [Hall plot]
Hall Mercy 1834 Dec 5 D ae 40; wife of William Hall [Hall plot]
Hall Rachel 1836 Mar 20 D ae 21; daughter of William Hall [Hall plot]
Hall Rachel [Austin] m Wife of Jonathan Hall [stone broken] [Hall plot]
Hall Ruth [1841 May 22] [D ae 1] daughter of William & E. Hall [stone broken and partially buried] [Hall plot]
Hall William 1842 Aug 3 D ae 53 [Hall plot]
Hall William J. 1842 Mar 29 D ae 2 months and 25 days; son of William & Elizabeth Hall
Hatmaker Bethiah C[hapman] [1901 Jun 10] D ae 79; wife of David Hatmaker [Chapman plot]
Hatmaker David [1898 Mar 31] D ae 88 [Chapman plot]
Henres Marthy 1853 Mar 21 D ae 48/5; wife of Aaron Henres
Holmes Brady # 1850 Apr D ae 7 in Benton [mortality schedule]
Jayne Eleanor [Vanzile] 1858 Sep 26 D ae 83/4; wife of Samuel Jayne [Sr.] [Jayne monument]
Jayne Elizabeth Bacon 1885 Feb 8 B1806 Feb 26 in England; wife of Samuel Jayne Jr.; died in Benton [Jayne monument]
Jayne Samuel Jr. 1893 Sep 3 B1804 Mar 3; son of Samuel & Eleanor Jayne; born & died in Benton [Jayne monument]
Jayne Samuel [Sr.] 1853 Apr 11 B1763 Mar 15, died age 90/27 days; Revolutionary War: Bayl's Co., 4th NY Militia [Jayne monument]
Jayne William 1830 Jan 14 D ae 16; son of Samuel & Eleanor Jayne [Jayne monument]
J[ewett] H[arman] [1871] [B1811] [footstone]
Jewett Mary 1835 Sep 17 D ae 72/11; wife of Jonathan Jewett
[Johnson?] ---- m [Three broken footstones in plot with the Wm Johnson monument]
Johnson? --ry m [Broken footstone in plot with the Wm Johnson monument]
Johnson Gilbert 1828 Sep 1 D ae 37/2/22 [John Johnson plot]
Johnson John Jr. 1833 Sep 4 B1752 May 2, died age 81/3/24; Revolutionary War: Orange Co., NY, Militia [John Johnson plot]
Johnson Lydia 1856 Jul 23 D ae 63/2/?; wife of Gilbert Johnson [John Johnson plot]
Johnson Mary 1840 Jan 31 D ae 89; wife of John Johnson [stone partially buried] [John Johnson plot]
Johnson Sarah A. Bews? 1904 Jan 7 D ae 65/4; wife of William Johnson [Wm Johnson monument]
Johnson William 1882 Jan 28 D ae 42/3 [Wm Johnson monument]
Johnson William H. 1871 Jan 12 D ae 17 days?; son of William Johnson [Wm Johnson monument]
Jolley Mary A. Smith 1897 [Sep 29] B1828 [died age 69/11/14]; wife of William Jolley [& daughter of William & Lucy Smith] [Jolley monument]
Jolley William 1904 B1820 [Jolley monument]
Jones Cordelia 1838 Aug 2 D ae 1 month and 26 days; daughter of Nicholas & Mary Jones [Jones plot]
Jones Edgar 1835 Mar 16 D ae 2 months and 10 days; son of Nicholas & Mary Jones [Jones plot]
Jones Mary 1846 Jan 24 [B1783] wife of Nicholas Jones [broken stone] [Jones plot]
K--- V--- B--- m [Unassigned footstone]
Kerney Elizabeth 1882 Oct 10 B1795 Apr 1; wife of James O. Kerney [Kerney plot]
Kerney James O. 1846 Apr 17 B1794 Jan 24 [Kerney plot]
Kerney John 1833 May 10 D 1/10/14; son of James & Elizabeth Kerney [Kerney plot]
Kerney Leah Ann # 1902 May 24 Infant daughter of James & Elizabeth Waldon Kerney [town record]
Kimball Daniel 1836 Feb 21 [B1752 Jan 11] died age 81
Kimball Mary 1835 Dec 26 D ae 83; wife of Daniel Kimball
Kipp Esther 1859 May 22 D ae 73/1/16; wife of Nicholas Kipp [Kipp plot]
Kipp Jane B. 1899 Jan 28 B1821 Dec 27; wife of John Kipp [Kipp plot]
Kipp John 1863 Feb 25 B1812 Oct 30 [Kipp plot]
Kipp Nicholas 1856 Jan 2 D ae 75/3/8 [Kipp plot]
Kipp Willie W. 1873 Sep 2 [Small monument, very worn] [Kipp plot; also recorded on the Marvin Kipp monument in Bellona Cemetery, Benton]
Lamb Austin W. 1840 Feb 3 D ae 3/11/17; son of William M. & S--- Lamb [Adjacent to Mary E. Lamb]
Lamb Mary E. 1840 Feb 15 D ae 2/7/16; daughter of William M. & S. T. Lamb [adjacent to Austin Lamb]
Lane Roland? 1851? [ ] -- D ae 5/10/22; son of -?- & -?- A. Lane [very worn]
M--- J--- M--- m [Unassigned footstone]
Mapes Ensley B[rown] 1877 Feb 5 B1870 Feb 8; son of Joseph & Rebecca Mapes [Mapes monument]
Mapes Joseph 1898 B1828 [Mapes monument]
Mapes Rebecca 1881 B1836; wife of Joseph Mapes [Mapes monument]
Mariner Buel 1852 Jan 6 D ae 77 [Mariner plot]
Mariner Esther [Lord] 1875 Sep 11 D ae 91/1/3; wife of Buel Mariner [Mariner plot]
Mariner Jay L. 1849 Oct 3 D ae 26/? /2 [broken stone] [Mariner plot]
Marlow Ann Moore 1906 B1829; wife of Robert Marlow [Marlow plot]
Marlow David M. 1859 Mar 9 D ae 3 months and 3 days; son of Robert & Ann Marlow [Marlow plot]
Marlow Rachel Ann E. 1876 Jun 21 D ae 9/8/25 [Marlow plot]
Marlow Robert 1866 Aug 18 D ae 33 [Marlow plot]
McDowell Mary [1884] B1796 Oct 4; wife of John McDowell [adjacent to Wm H. Whitaker monument]
McFarren Jane 1864 Jul 22 B1802 May 13 [McFarren plot]
McFarren Samuel 1828 Feb 18 B1760 Sep 8; died age 67/5/10; Revolutionary War: Northampton Co., Penn. Militia [McFarren plot]
McFarren Susannah [Campbell] 1856 Jul 31 [D ae 75/5/17] wife of Samuel McFarren [broken stone] [McFarren plot]
McFarren [William] 1827 --- 27 [D ae 23; son of Samu]el & [Susannah] McFarren [slate stone, inscription broken off] [McFarren plot]
McKane Gilbert Mattire Delafayette 1833 Jul 21 D ae 3/2; son of Samuel & Deborah McKane [McKane plot]
McKane Madison G. 1839 Aug 27 D ae 11/7/4; son of Samuel & Deborah A McKane [McKane plot]
McKane Robert 1838 Jan 5 D ae 81/8/5
McKane Robert M. 1850 Sep 18 B1800 May 11 [McKane plot]
McKane Samuel 1844 Apr 19 D ae 55/8; killed while moving his house [McKane plot]
McKane Sarah 1839 Oct 23 D ae 80/7/15 w/o R[obert] McKane [McKane plot]
McKane Syntha Ann 1839 Aug 29 D ae 1/2/19 [McKane plot]
McMaster Dewitt C. 1827 Apr 2 B1824 Jul 6; son of James & Jemima McMaster
[McMaster Mary A.] m [B1838; wife of J. J. McMaster] [matching stone face down adjacent to John J. McMaster]
McMillan Daniel B. 1843 Dec 12 D ae 23/3/24; son of John & Clarinda McMillan [McMillan plot]
McMillan John 1837 Dec 29 D ae 52 [McMillan plot]
McMillen George m Son of John & Clarinda McMillen [stone partially buried] [McMillen plot]
Mead Catherine 1882 May 20 D ae 72/1/20; wife of Gilbert Mead [Mead plot] [broken stone]
Mead George W. 1891 May 19 B1840 Jan 30 [Mead plot]
Mead Gilbert 1884 Nov 5 D ae 7/11/10 [son of Joshua & Phebe Haight Mead] [broken stone] [Mead plot]
Mead Joshua 1866 Feb 4 B1790 Jul 29, died age 75/7/5 [Mead plot]
Mead Kate Whitaker 1930 B1851; wife of George W. Mead [Mead plot]
Mead Phoebe 1866 May 24 B1790 Mar 12, died age 76/2/12; wife of Joshua Mead [Mead plot]
Mead William 1838 Sep 7 D ae 22/7/12; son of Joshua & Phoebe Mead [Mead plot]
Meserole Abigail 1833 Apr 25 B1831 Aug 3, died age 1/8/22; daughter of Jacob & Ann Meserole [Jacob Meserole monument & her own stone]
Meserole Ann Remsen 1872 Apr 17 D ae 71; wife of Jacob Meserole [Jacob Meserole monument]
Meserole Anthony S. 1846 Nov 20 D ae 2/2/7 [Peter Meserole monument]
Meserole Eliza S. 1881 Mar 10 D ae 67/9/9 [wife of Peter P. Meserole] [Peter Meserole monument]
Meserole Jacob 1874 Aug 22 D ae 71/7 [Jacob Meserole monument]
Meserole Jeremiah Remsen 1845 Jun 16 B1827 Feb 2; son of Jacob & Ann Meserole [Jacob Meserole monument and his own stone]
Meserole Peter P. 1885 Dec 2 D ae 78/10/08 [Peter Meserole monument]
Mitchells Anna Spink # 1861 Mar 20 B1817 Dec 17; wife of Robert Mitchells
Mitchells Elizabeth 1844 Dec 3 D ae 74/8; wife of William Mitchells [Mitchells plot]
Mitchells Elizabeth Ann 1844 Apr 2 D ae 3/6/11; daughter of Robert & Anna Mitchells [Mitchells plot]
Mitchells infant 1844 Feb 5 D ae 3 months 16 days; son of R. & A. Mitchells [Mitchells plot]
Mitchells Robert 1887 Sep 14 B1800 Jan 4 [Mitchells plot]
Mitchells William 1847 Nov 19 D ae 82/9 [Mitchells plot]
[Mittauer?] ---- 1833 Apr 24 [Slate stone with inscription gone, matches Andrew Mittauer stone; John Johnson plot]
Mittauer Andrew m D ae 78 [Johnson plot]
Moor Elizabeth 1858 Oct 12 D ae 3 months and 2 days; daughter of F. & E. Moor [Moor plot]
Moor Ella 1867 Apr 11 D ae 6 days; daughter of F. & E. Moor [Moor plot]
Moor Sarah A. 1862 Oct 3 D ae 5 months and 19 days; daughter of F. & E. Moor [Moor plot]
Moshier Sarah A. 1851 Apr 29 D ae 1/1; daughter of W. S. & Ann E. Moshier
Noble Isabella 1891 B1841; wife of Samuel Noble
Noble Samuel 1927 B1842
O--- M--- m [Unassigned footstone]
Oldfield Abraham # 1818 Aug 20 D in Benton [estate inventory]
Oldfield Olive Kidder # 1860 Feb D ae 70 in Benton; wife of Abraham Oldfield [mortality schedule]
Olmstead Cynthia 1872 Mar 27 D ae 71; wife of Francis Olmstead [Olmstead monument]
Olmstead Emily 1863 Jun 25 D ae 62 [Olmstead monument]
Olmstead Francis 1872 Dec 19 D ae 76 [Olmstead monument]
P--- A--- E--- m [Unassigned footstone]
P[ow] J[ames ] M. [1880 Mar 24] [D ae 72/11/28] [fallen headstone & footstone] [Pow plot]
Pow Lovisa [Swarthout] 1869 Feb 18 D ae 57/10/17; wife of James M. Pow [Pow plot]
R?--- C--- m [Unassigned footstone]
Rich [Jane] 1893 B1833; wife of Benjamin Rich [stone partially buried]
Robinson Emeline 1888 B1812; wife of James Robinson
Robinson James 1879 B1810
Robson Isabella 1855 Sep 1 D ae 82/3/20; wife of Robert Robson [& mother of James M. Pow] [Robson plot]
Robson Mary 1836 Jun 12 D ae 18/6/8; daughter of Robert & Isabella Robson [Robson plot]
Robson Robert 1851 May 13 D ae 81/6/4 [Robert Robson plot]
Roy Charles 1871 Oct 23 B1804 May 21, died age 67/5; son of William & Deborah Roy [Roy plot]
Roy Chester 1859 Sep 5 D ae 21/11/15; son of Charles & Elizabeth Roy [Roy plot]
Roy Deborah [Whitaker] 1851 Jul 20 D ae 68/6/12; wife of William Roy [Jr.] [& daughter of Stephen & Ruth Whitaker] [Roy plot]
Roy Elizabeth M. 1882 Dec 24 B1806 Dec 23, died age 76/9; wife of Charles Roy [Roy plot]
Roy H--- m [Unassigned footstone]
Roy William 1843 Apr 25 D ae 65/1/15 [Roy plot]
Scott Garret V. 1853 Dec 16 D ae 32/3/27 [Scott plot]
Scott Helen Ophelia 1852? Dec 7 D ae 6/? /5; daughter of G[arret V.] & Mary M. Scott [Scott plot]
Scott Samuel W. 1831 Nov 15 D ae 39 [Scott plot]
Scott William 1833 Oct 11 D ae 2/4; son of Samuel & Ann Scott
Sherland Ann G. McLean # 1897 Feb 10 D ae 94, born 1803 May 10 in Columbia Co., NY; daughter of John D. & Jane Comer McLean & wife of William Sherland
Sherland William # 1898 Oct 22 D ae 92 in Benton , born in Mass.
Smith Lucy L. 1875 B1801 [adjacent to Jolley monument]
Sones Edatha Belt 1885 Apr 1 D ae 87; wife of William Sones [Sones monument]
Sones Esther 1847 Nov 14 D ae 7; daughter of W. & E. Sones [Sones monument]
Sones James 1864 May 1 D ae 21; son of W. & E. Sones; killed at Spottsylvania, Civil War [Sones monument]
Sones William 1884 Apr 11 D ae 85/6 [Sones monument]
Southerland Abert 1839 Mar 4 D ae 24/10/2 [Southerland plot]
Southerland Elizabeth m Wife of John Southerland [broken stone] [Southerland plot]
Southerland Gilbert 1831 Apr 18 D ae 22/4/18, drowned in Seneca Lake [Southerland plot]
Southerland John 1855 Mar 3 D ae 87/2/4 [broken stone] [Southerland plot]
Speelman Nancy 1826 Jan 24 D ae 20/3/9; daughter of David & Elizabeth Speelman
Stryker Eliza 1875 Jan 31 D ae 5, "lived most of her life with the family of Samuel Jayne"
Swarthout Aaron E. 1881 Sep 24 B1820 Jan 22 [son of John Swarthout] [Aaron Swarthout monument]
Swarthout Amanda 1897 Feb 15 D ae 77/2; wife of W. D. Swarthout [W. D. Swarthout monument; John L. Swarthout plot]
Swarthout Anthony 1857 Mar 18 D ae 75/11/18; War of 1812 [Anthony Swarthout monument]
Swarthout Augusta 1848 Oct 26 D ae 3/11/12; daughter of William D. & Amanda Swarthout [John L. Swarthout plot]
Swarthout Catherine E. 1849 Sep 9 D ae 4 [Owen Swarthout monument]
Swarthout Clarissa [Nutt] 1906 Jul 26 [B1818] died age 78 [wife of J. C. Swarthout] [age should be 88]
Swarthout Elizabeth 185? Apr D ae 96; wife of John Swarthout [very worn] [Anthony Swarthout monument]
Swarthout Frances A. 1860 Jun 13 B1851 Jul 9 [Aaron Swarthout monument]
Swarthout Hannah [Chapman] 1859 Nov 22 D ae 76/7; wife of Anthony Swarthout [& daughter of Josiah Chapman] [Anthony Swarthout monument]
Swarthout Henrietta F. 1862 Jan 21 B1855 Aug 12 [Aaron Swarthout monument]
Swarthout Irene 1836 Mar 25 D ae 20/1/10; daughter of Anthony & Hannah Swarthout
S[warthout] I[rene] B. [1893 Oct 21] [D ae 65; sister in law of James M. Pow] [fallen headstone & footstone; Pow plot]
Swarthout Irene [Chapman] 1838 Aug 22 D ae 47/3/6; wife of John L. Swarthout [& daughter of Josiah Chapman] [John L. Swarthout plot]
Swarthout Jemima E. [Trimmer] 1903 Jan 27 B1828 Apr 20; wife of Aaron E. Swarthout [& daughter of Epenetus & Rebecca Trimmer] [Aaron Swarthout monument]
Swarthout John L. 1849 Dec 15 D ae 65/1/15 [John L. Swarthout plot]
Swarthout John M. 1855 Aug 16 D ae 2 [Owen Swarthout monument]
Swarthout J[osiah] C[hapman] 1866 Jan 27 D ae 57/5/26
Swarthout Lucy 1897 Nov 13 D ae 53; wife of Edgar Swarthout [W. D. Swarthout monument; John L. Swarthout plot]
Swarthout Maria A. [Meserole] 1881 Sep 9 B1811 Oct 12; wife of Owen R. Swarthout [Owen Swarthout monument]
Swarthout Netus 1860 Jun 17 B1856 Dec 22 [Aaron Swarthout monument]
Swarthout Owen R. 1855 Oct 31 D ae 5 [Owen Swarthout monument]
Swarthout Owen R. 1883 Feb 2 B1811 Mar 4 [Owen Swarthout monument]
Swarthout Ray 1896 Mar 14 B1863 Aug 1; son of Aaron & Jemima Swarthout [Aaron Swarthout monument]
Swarthout W. D. 1907 Mar 16 D ae 89/3 [W. D. Swarthout monument; John L. Swarthout plot]
Thomas Hannah Scott # 1891 Sep 16 D ae 75/5/2 in Penn Yan; daughter of Samuel & Mary Coats Scott [town record]
Townsend Mary W. 1846 Oct 28 D ae 19 [broken stone] [Scott plot]
Tremper John 1822 Aug 31 D ae 29/3/28 at Capt. Aaron Remer's house in Benton; son of Henry & Elizabeth Tremper; born Philadelphia, Penn.
Trimmer Anna # 1838 D ae 11/9/6; daughter of Anthony Trimmer Jr.
Trimmer Anna [Ganung] 1838 B1797; wife of Anthony Trimmer Jr. & daughter of William Ganung [footstone; headstone very worn] [Anthony Trimmer plot]
Trimmer Anthony 1838 Sep 23 D ae 84; Revolutionary War: Cumberland Co., Penn. Militia [Anthony Trimmer plot]
Trimmer Anthony Jr. 1863 Dec 6 B1785 Sep 16 [son of Anthony & Sarah Trimmer] War of 1812: ord. sgt., 2nd NY Militia [Anthony Trimmer plot]
Trimmer Ellen J. [Perine] 1877 Feb 10 B1831 Mar 31 [wife of Ellsworth Trimmer] [broken stone]
T[rimmer] E[llsworth] [1897 Apr 29] [B1832; son of Epenetus & Rebecca Trimmer] [footstone in plot adjacent to Ellen Trimmer]
Trimmer Epenetus H[art] 1857 Apr D ae 65/11/20 [son of Anthony & Sarah Trimmer] [broken stone]
Trimmer John # 1912 Feb 21 D ae 90 in Benton; son of Anthony Jr. & Anna Genung Trimmer [obituary]
Trimmer Mary B., Mrs. # 1919 Dec 21 D in Penn Yan, buried at Mt. Pleasant [obituary]
Trimmer Rebecca [Ellis] 1868 Aug 28 [B1803] wife of Epenetus Trimmer [& daughter of William Ellis] [broken stone]
Trimmer Ruth C. 1866 Oct 7 D ae 18/11/6 [daughter of Epenetus & Rebecca Trimmer] [broken stone]
Trimmer Sarah 1837 Nov 5 D ae 8/1/14; daughter of Epenetus & Rebecca Trimmer [Anthony Trimmer plot]
Trimmer Sarah [Howard] 1832 Mar 24 D ae 73/7/27; wife of Anthony Trimmer [Anthony Trimmer plot]
Trimmer Thomas H. 1851 Apr 7 B1797 Jan 22 [son of Anthony & Sarah Trimmer] [Anthony Trimmer plot]
Trimmer Thomas H. 1853 Oct 9 D ae 16/5/9 [son of Epenetus & Rebecca Trimmer] [Anthony Trimmer plot]
Trimmer Zella 1851 Sep 30 D ae 1/11; son of E. & E. J. Trimmer
Turner Sarah? 1854? Apr 29 B1854 --- 25; daughter of -?- & S. A. Turner; "Little Sarah?" [very worn]
VanCourt Sarah 1822 May 18 B1772 Jan 13; died age 49/8/5; wife of David VanCourt
Vandeventer Ruth [Whitaker Mallory] 1850 Oct 16 D ae 63/10/27; wife of Jacob Vandeventer [her 1st husband was Ephraim Mallory; daughter of Stephen & Ruth Whitaker] [Roy plot]
Vanwinkle Jacob 1837 Jan 23 D ae 19/7/23 [son of Albert & Margaret Bush Vanwinkle] [Bush plot]
Walden John W. 1852 Jun 10 D ae 84/2/10
Walden Leah 1867 Dec 18 D ae 9719/29; wife of John Walden
Waldon Catherine A. 1878 Dec 11 D ae 75/8/12
Wallace Barbara Grant 1892 B1808; wife of James Wallace
Wallace James 1886 B1800
Warren Mary E. # 1874 Nov 10 D ae 27 in Benton [mortality schedule]
Whitaker Agnes [VanCourt Potter] 1837 Aug 21 D ae 64/6; [4th] wife of Stephen Whitaker [& widow of Daniel Potter] [Stephen Whitaker plot]
Whitaker Alice A. 1938 B1849 [daughter of William Harlow Whitaker] [Wm H. Whitaker monument]
Whitaker Ann Eliza [McDowell] 1904 Oct 15 B1817 Nov 2 [wife of William Harlow Whitaker] [Wm H. Whitaker monument]
Whitaker Augustus 1866 Mar 20 B1843 Jun 2; son of W. H. & A. E. Whitaker [Wm H. Whitaker monument]
Whitaker Charles A. # 1850 Feb D ae 3 months in Benton [mortality schedule]
Whitaker Cora B. 1895 B1852 [Squier Whitaker monument]
Whitaker Eliza W. Bates 1886 Jul 8 B1820 Jul 26; wife of E[phraim] M. Whitaker [& daughter of Linus Bates] [Ephraim Whitaker monument]
Whitaker Ephraim M. 1880 Feb 15 B1816 Aug 27 [son of Jonathan & Mary Whitaker] Civil War [Ephraim Whitaker monument]
Whitaker George 1825 Jul 26 D ae 20 months; son of Jonathan & Mary Whitaker [Stephen Whitaker plot]
Whitaker H. B. m Infant [Squier Whitaker monument]
Whitaker Herbert B. 1859 Jun 14 B1850 Oct 6; son of E[phraim] M. & E. W. Whitaker [Ephraim Whitaker monument]
Whitaker James S. 1920 B1852 [son of Squire & Lydia Whitaker] [Squier Whitaker monument]
Whitaker Jonathan 1856 Apr 12 B1780 Jan 21 [son of Stephen and Ruth Whitaker] [Stephen Whitaker plot]
Whitaker Lydia C. [Amsbury] 1852 Jan 24 D ae 32; [2nd] wife of Squier B. Whitaker [Squier Whitaker monument]
Whitaker Marietta 1923 B1845 [daughter of William Harlow Whitaker] [Wm H. Whitaker monument]
[Whitaker?] Mary m [Small stone near Wm H. Whitaker monument]
Whitaker Mary [Bailey] 1854 Aug 27 B1784 Aug 27; wife of Jonathan Whitaker [Stephen Whitaker plot]
Whitaker Mercy [Amsbury] 1840 Aug 25 D ae 32/5/24; [1st] wife of Squier B. Whitaker [Squier Whitaker monument]
Whitaker Squier B[ailey] 1884 Aug 29 D ae 77/3; son of Jonathan & Mary Whitaker [Squier Whitaker monument]
Whitaker Stephen 1827 Nov 4 B1747 Jan 10, died age 81; Revolutionary War: 3rd Lieut., N.J. Militia [Stephen Whitaker plot]
Whitaker William Harlow 1881 Jul 29 B1813 Aug 16; son of Jonathan & Mary Whitaker [Wm H. Whitaker monument]
Winters Adaline # 1898 Feb 25 D ae 66; daughter of Henry & Nancy L. Kidder Winters [town record]
Winters Henry 1861 Sep 5 D ae 63/11/13 [Winters monument]
[Winters Myron] [1846] [B1835] [probably on the underside of fallen Winters monument; also his own stone in Townsend Cemetery, Benton]
Winters Nancy C. 1872 Mar 16 D ae 66/8/3; wife of Henry Winters [Winters monument]
Winters Samuel K. # 1905 Mar 7 D ae 75/11; son of Henry & Lucy Kidder Winters [town record]
[Winters William] [1869 Sep] [B1828] [probably on the underside of fallen Winters monument]
Wonzer Reliance I. 1885 Oct 25 D ae 57; wife of Isaac Wonzer
Wood Eli 1855 Nov 24 B1796 Mar 23
Wood Eliza 1880 Nov 22 B1801 Dec 25; wife of Eli Wood

For help with abbreviations and conventions, click here.