[Home] [Cemetery page] [Starkey cemetery page] [Starkey Index] [General Index]


Yates County Cemetery Project
Part VIII: Cemeteries in the town of Starkey


 

Starkey Methodist Cemetery: Notes


Starkey Methodist cemetery This old churchyard is now associated with the adjacent church, the oldest in the town and in fact the oldest remaining church building in the county. The congregation does not however own the cemetery, and has been keeping it up in recent years out of the goodness of their hearts.

The ground is easily accessible from the road, located just behind the beautiful little church. It is in quite good condition despite its age.

 

Starkey Methodist Cemetery: Burials


---- ---- m [Plain fieldstone adjacent to Wm Beard]
---- ---- 1859 Sep 14 D ae 61 [broken stone]
---- Frankie m m
---- Freddie m m
---- Winnie m m
Andrews Anna 1875 Jun 15 D ae 87/6/5; wife of Jonathan Andrews
Andrews Jonathan 1857 Sep 14 Son of Jonathan & Anna Andrews [broken stone]
Andrews Jonathan 1865 Jan 8 D ae 76/2/8
B--- P--- m [Footstone]
Beard William 1830 Feb 26 D ae 69/9/10
B[eers?] S--- m [Large slate stone, name obliterated; footstone]
Beers Silas 1829 Jul 22 D ae 58/2/29
Best Stout 1887 Oct 16 B1876 Sep 12; son of Robert & Olive Best
Brewer Charles Raymond 1946 B1879 [Brewer lot]
Brewer Edith Marshall 1989 B1888 DAR
Brewer Ella Pettingill # 1911 B1876
Brewer Ellem M. 1980 B1916; WWII: t/sgt., U.S. Army [Brewer lot]
Brewer James L. # 1909 Jan 29 D ae 62/3/24 in Starkey, son of Lucius & Amanda Brewer [town record]
Brewer Rosalee Ann 1936 B1918 [Brewer lot]
Brundage Anna 1880 Feb 21 D ae 85/8/12; "Mother"; wife of Ebenezer Brundage
Burgett Libbie Pratt 1909 B1865; daughter of John W. & Mary A. Pratt
Cambell Alice M. 1889 Oct 26 D ae 5/3/6; daughter of Joseph & Phebe Campbell [Campbell monument]
Campbell Grantie 1878 Oct 21 D ae 10/2/2; son of Joseph & Phebe Campbell [Campbell monument]
Campbell Joseph 1893 Oct 14 D ae 55/1/14 [Campbell monument]
Campbell Joseph 1893 B1806; Civil War: Co. A, 50th NY Engineers
Casad Katherine 1824 Nov 16 D ae 78
Casterline Elijah 1878 Dec 29 D ae 53
Casterline [Sarah] Maria Andrews 1885 Mar 20 B1831 Feb 6; wife of Elijah Casterline
Christy Lewis B. # 1905 Jan 20 D ae 71 in Starkey, son of Andrew & Catharine Sears Christy [town record]
Christy Mary E. Dense # 1902 Nov 19 D ae 69/19 days in Starkey, daughter of William Dense [town record]
Clark Frank M. 1910 B1885 [Clark monument]
Clark Hattie E. Meeks 1954 B1864; wife of Myron B. Clark [Clark Monument]
Clark Myron B. 1925 B1861 [Clark monument]
Darmrood? Frank # 1864 Nov 12 D ae 7 in Starkey [mortality schedule]
Davenport Henry H. 1867 Oct 15 B1775 Aug 19
Dense Ann Scribner # 1893 Mar 6 D ae 72/4/25 in Dundee, daughter of --?-- & Polly Rhinevault Scribner [village record]
Dense Caroline 1849 May 23 D ae 12/7/14; daughter of William & Sophronia Dense
Dense Caroline 1857 Jan 30 D ae 48/10/29; wife of Elijah Dense
Dense Charles [1891 Dec 30] [D ae 50] Civil War: Co. K, 100th NY
Dense Elijah 1899 B1834
Dense Fanny # 1905 Jul 12 D ae 45 in Penn Yan, daughter of Elijah & Rebecca McGown Dense [village record]
Dense James 1844 Dec? 18 D ae 1?/10/5, son of -?- H? & Sarah? Dense
Dense Lydia 1856 Apr 24 D ae 4/10, daughter of William & Sophronia Dense
Dense Mary 1844 Jul 14 D ae 2/10/24, daughter of Elijah & Caroline Dense
Dense Rebecca A. [McGown] 1892 B1834, wife of Elijah Dense
Dense Sarah 1850 Feb 16 D ae 7 months 22 days, daughter of William & Sophronia Dense
Dense Sophronia 1868 Jul 22 D ae 56/16 days, wife of William Dense
Dense William # 1894 Apr 17 D ae 83/9 in Starkey [town record]
Dense William R. 1850? D ae 21/6/6, son of William & Sophronia Dense [worn]
Dodge George C. 1829 May 9 D ae 7 months & 2 days, son of Jonas & Carrista Dodge
Drake Garshom 1823 Jul 22 D ae 1/9/2, son of Philip L. & Rebecca Drake
Drake infant 1828 Mar 13 Daughter of Philip L. Drake
Drake Rebecca [Brown] 1828 Mar 12 D ae 32/9 days, [2nd] wife of Philip L. Drake
Drake Sarah H. 1825 Jul 24 D ae 11 months & 11 days, daughter of Philip L. Drake
Dunlap Anson C. 1911 B1823 [Dunlap monument]
Dunlap Dorothy A. 1961 Mar 8 B1899 Jul 14
Dunlap Evaline Gulick 1915 B1825, wife of Anson C. Dunlap
Dunlap Helen Backer m B1871, wife of John J. Dunlop [Dunlap monument]
Dunlap infant # 1883 Oct 5 D ae 5 months 20 days in Starkey, daughter of John & Charlene Dunlap [town record]
Dunlap John J. m B1859 [Dunlap monument]
Dunn Fanny M. 1883 May 17 B1811 Jun 30 [Tuthill lot]
Dunn Susannah, Mrs. 1851? Nov? 8 D ae 80 [stone broken]
Foltz Frank J. 1940 B1867 [Foltz monument]
Foltz Kathryn 1947 B1865, wife of Frank J. Foltz [Foltz monument]
Foltz Leon C. 1914 B1902 [Foltz monument]
Fowler John T. # 1864 Nov 24 D ae 1/9 in Starkey [mortality schedule]
Gano Charles R. 1841 Apr 19 D ae 8 months & 4 days, son of J. B. & Adaline [Reeder] Gano
Gilbert Arthur M. 1942 Sep 20 WWI
Gilbert Flora P. 1954 B1866 [wife of Frank S. Gilbert]
Gilbert Frank S. 1924 B1859
Gilbert Howard J. 1969 May 12 B1919 Jan 27; WWII: NY, Quartermaster Corps
Gilbert John 1964 Feb 7 B1893 Nov 18; WWI
Gilbert Melvin P. 1943 B1887
Gilbert Myrtle P. m B1897, wife of Melvin P. Gilbert
Green Percy Oliver # 1903 Oct 4 D ae 8 months 17 days in Starkey, son of Benjamin & Lucy Granby Green [town record]
Griswold John 1847 Dec 22 B1758 Jun 29; Revolutionary War: 6th Connecticut Regiment
Griswold Rhoda 1821 Oct 15 D ae 58, wife of John Griswold
Gulick Egbert # 1895 Jul 7 D ae 62 in Starkey [town record]
Halsey Susannah 1847 Sep 9 D ae 69/8/22, wife of Silas Halsey
Hinckley Sophia Stewart 1885 Apr 15 B1791 Oct 13 in Coleraine Mass., died in Starkey
Hodges Triphena # 1870 Apr D ae 71 in Starkey; widow; born in Mass. [mortality schedule]
Hurd Fanny T[uthill] 1878 Mar 19 B1799 Nov 15; wife of Harry Hurd [& daughter of Joshua Tuthill]
H[urd] H[arry] [1844] Mar 14 D ae 44 [son of Timothy & Mabel Booth Hurd] [broken stone and footstone adjacent to Fanny Hurd]
Hurd? Harry B. 1843 Sep 25 D ae 1/3/1, son of J. H. & S. -?- H[urd?]
Huson Mary Ann [Harpending] 1828 Nov 11 D ae 21/2/11, [1st] wife of Samuel Huson [& daughter of Samuel Harpending]
Huston William [B.] 1858 Jul 12 B1787 in Coleraine, Co. Antrim, Ireland; died age 71 in Starkey
Hyatt Anne 1871 May 14 B1800 Jun 16, wife of John W. Hyatt [Hyatt / Sutfin monument]
Hyatt Ellen J. 1861 Feb 4 B1823 Jun 2, wife of J. G. Hyatt [Hyatt / Sutfin monument]
Hyatt John W. 1871 May 7 B1794 Apr 7 [Hyatt / Sutfin monument]
Hyatt Nancy S. 1846 Apr 28 B1825 Nov 3, daughter of John W. & Anne Hyatt [Hyatt / Sutfin monument]
Hyatt Winnie # 1865 Jan 7 D ae 6 in Starkey [mortality schedule]
Jordan Lizetta m [Quick / Lott / Jordan monument; no dates]
Kingin Joshua T. 1841 Oct 6 D ae 28 [son of Andrew & Anna Young Kingin]
Kingin Mary J[ane Chandler] Fowler 1882 Jun 26 D ae 67/4/12 days, wife of Joshua Kingin [her 1st husband was Ira Fowler]
Knapp Orville A. 1879 Oct 6 D ae 2 months & 5 days, son of Charles & Marilla Knapp
Kress Elizabeth [Starkey] 1828 Nov 6 D ae 36, [1st] wife of Samuel Kress
Kress Hester A. 1849 Nov 11 D ae 2/2/14, daughter of A. & H. Kress
Kress Hester Ann [Fellows] 1847 Sep 2 D ae 18/11/22, wife of A[ndrew P.] T. Kress & daughter of Rev. N. & E. Fellows
Lane Dewitt # 1902 Sep 24 D ae 2/1/19 in Dundee, son of Ben & Grace Lane [village record]
Lane Hattie M. 1892 Feb 7 D ae 42, wife of Charles Lane; "Mother"
Layton Abigail 1859 Sep 23 D ae 53, wife of Jesse Layton [Tuthill lot]
Layton Charles Tuthill 1830 Jul 26 D ae 8 months, son of J. S. & Abigail Layton
Layton Fanny Mariah 1827 Aug 29 D ae 14 days, daughter of Jesse S. Layton
Lee Peter A. # 1860 Apr D ae 3 in Starkey; possibly son of Peter & C. Lee & grandson of Isaac & Susan Morrison [mortality schedule]
Lott Clara # 1888 Nov 3 D ae 2 days in Starkey [town record]
Lott Julia m [Quick / Lott / Jordan monument; no dates]
McLoud Eliza A[nn Kress] 1882 Apr 29 B1813 Sep 20, wife of Shannon McLoud [& daughter of J. J. & Margaret Kress] [McLoud monument]
McLoud Montgomery 1885 Jul 20 B1837 May 11 [son of Shannon & Eliza McLoud] [McLoud monument]
McLoud Sarah E. 1917 Feb 6 B1839 Aug 17, wife of Montgomery McLoud [McLoud monument]
McLoud Shannon 1862 Apr 18 B1809 Aug 31 [McLoud monument]
McMullen William # 1870 Jan D ae 24 in Starkey, born in Ireland; son of Andrew & Hannah McMullen [mortality schedule]
McSwain Horace m m
McSwain Melissa m m
McSwain Stephen R. # 1850 Jun D ae 10 in Starkey [mortality schedule]
Morehead Marinda # 1875 Jan 24 D ae 22 in Starkey, wife of James Morehead [mortality schedule]
O'Daniels Elizabeth 1868 B1797, wife of John R. O'Daniels; "Mother"
O'Daniels John R. 1851 Mar 6 B1796 Nov 23
Ovenshire W. Eugene 1895 Sep 5 B1851 Oct 11
P--- W--- m [Footstone]
Patterson James Henry # 1865 Feb 26 D ae 1/6 in Starkey [mortality schedule]
Pettingill Ellen Struble 1909 B1831, wife of William B. Pettingill
Pettingill Mertie 1870 Apr 15 D ae 6 months & 15 day, daughter of William B. & Ellen Pettingill
Pettingill William B. 1905 B1825
P[otter?] A[lanson?] m [Footstone]
Potter Susan A. 1875 Aug 30 D ae 34, wife of Alanson Potter
Pratt John W. 1912 Oct 17 B1843 Mar 13
Pratt Mary A. 1919 Aug 29 B1845 Jun 15, wife of John W. Pratt
Quick Amanda 1880 Jun 19 D ae 52, wife of Jackson Quick [Quick monument]
Quick Ann Eliza # 1891 Nov 30 D ae 72/5/10 in Starkey, born in Penn.; daughter of Henry Quick [town record]
Quick Emmet T. 1859 Mar 12 D ae 1 month 20 days, son of Jackson & Amanda Quick [Quick monument]
Quick Jackson 1884 Nov 25 D ae 68/10/13
Quick Lewis m [Quick / Lott / Jordan monument; no dates]
Quick Louisa m [Quick / Lott / Jordan monument; no dates]
Raplee Daniel J. 1828 Oct 28 D ae 7/5/27, son of James Rapalee [Sr.]
Reed Catharine [Kress] 1848 Mar 31 D ae 36/2/11, wife of Elisha C. Reed & daughter of John J. & Margaret Kress
[Reeder?] ---- 1831 Apr 29 D ae 28/9/8 [broken stone adjacent to Stephen Reeder]
Reeder Amy [R.] 1829 Mar 10 D ae 78/2/23, wife of Samuel Reeder
Reeder Angeline [Adams] 1891 Jan 16 B1814 Oct 30, wife of James M. Reeder [Reeder monument]
Reeder Benjamin F. # 1856 B1821, son of Stephen & Catharine Reeder
[Reeder?] Catherine [Drake] [1834] Sep -- [B1778], wife of Stephen [Reeder?] [broken stone]
Reeder George A. 1899 Apr 12 B1835 Nov 23 [son of James M. & Angeline Reeder] [Reeder monument]
Reeder Henry [R.] 1850 Jul 10 B1849 Jun 12 [Reeder monument]
Reeder James H. 1876 Jun 7 B1839 Nov 22 [son of James M. & Angeline Reeder] [Reeder monument]
Reeder James M. 1873 Jun 29 B1811 Aug 18 [son of Stephen & Catharine Reeder] [Reeder monument]
Reeder Joseph Warren 1862 Sep 25 D ae [53]/3, [son of Stephen & Catharine Reeder] [stone broken]
Reeder Lucy A. 1917 Feb 12 B1855 Nov 29 [daughter of James M. & Angeline Reeder] [Reeder monument]
Reeder Lyman 1904 Feb 14 B1843 Dec 27 [son of James M. & Angeline Reeder] [Reeder monument]
Reeder Maria A. 1857 Jan 11 B1838 Apr 13 [daughter of James M. & Angeline Reeder] [Reeder monument]
R[eeder] S[ilvester] [1834] [B1806 son of Stephen & Catharine Reeder] [footstone]
Reeder Stephen 1850 Oct 2 D ae 77 [son of Samuel & Amy Reeder]
Reeder William C. 1861 Apr 11 B1858 Dec 7; "Willie" [Reeder monument]
Rich Erastus 1821 Jan 25 D ae 13 son of Alfred Rich
Rich Sarah [Griswold] 1823 Nov 12 D ae 39 wife of Alfred Rich [& daughter of John Griswold]
[Robinson?] Delores 1834 D ae 78/7 [broken stone]
Robinson John, Rev. 1868 Jan 9 D ae 65
Roleson Anna G. 1854 Jul 28 B1827 Aug 9, wife of Britton Roleson
S--- C--- A. m [Footstone]
S--- E--- R. m [Footstone]
Salisbury Ida A. # 1864 Jul 12 D ae 4 in Starkey [mortality schedule]
Shannon Huldah A. [McLoud] 1891 Aug 10 D ae 55/5/15, wife of L. M. Shannon [& daughter of Shannon & Eliza McLoud] [McLoud monurnent]
Shannon Lewis M. 1910 B1830 [son of Thomas J. & Jane Dunn Shannon]
Shrauger Richard A. 1933 B1932
Simonson William A. 1853 Jan 13 D ae 11/23 days, son of Joel C. & Julia A. Simonson
Smith Emma O? 1864 Apr 2 D ae , daughter of Lewis & Emily Smith
Smith Nelson W. 1859 Feb 4 D ae 11 months, son of Lewis & Emily Smith
Smith Polly 1822 Dec 9 D ae 35, wife of Joseph Smith
Smith Rebecca 1826 Aug 6 D ae 16/9, daughter of Joseph & Polly Smith
Starkey George # 1820 May 1 D ae 1/7/2, son of John Starkey
Starkey John Wesley 1822 Aug 23 D ae 15 months 7 days, son of John Starkey
Stephens Luther # 1903 Nov 21 D ae 78 in Dundee [village record]
Stout Sarah Ayres # 1850 Apr D ae 65 in Starkey; lst wife of John Stout; born in NJ [mortality schedule]
Sutfin Rachel 1855 Mar 25 B1769 Mar 20 [Hyatt / Sutfin monument]
Tuthill Benjamin 1856 Mar 15 B1801 May 26 [son of Joshua & Sarah Tuthill] [Tuthill monument]
Tuthill Frances T. 1850 Jan 10 D ae 3/9/10, daughter of Charles G. & E[lizabeth Castner] Tuthill
Tuthill Joshua 1849 May 2 D ae 74/8 [Tuthill monument]
Tuthill Minerva R. 1856 Jan 20 D ae 15/11/6, daughter of Benjamin & Rebecca H. Tuthill [Tuthill monument]
Tuthill Rebecca [Dunn] 1882 Jan 19 B1801 Feb 1, wife of Benjamin Tuthill [Tuthill monument]
Tuthill Sarah E. 1855 May 5 D ae 7/7/11, daughter of Benjamin & Rebecca H. Tuthill [Tuthill monument]
Tuthill Sarah [Reeder] 1843 Apr 13 D ae 60/5/6; wife of Joshua Tuthill [& daughter of Samuel & Amy Reeder] [Tuthill monument]
Tuthill Theron 1843 Apr 19 D ae 18, son of Benjamin & Rebecca Tuthill [Tuthill monument]
VanAllen Adalaide 1840 Aug 27 D ae 16 days, daughter of G. W. & Susan VanAllen
VanAllen Adaline 1849 Jun 14 D ae 8/10/3, daughter of Geo W. & Susan [Reeder] VanAllen
VanAllen M. H. 1840 Aug 27 D ae 11, daughter of George & Susan VanAllen
VanAllen Maria Jane 1842 Mar 5 D ae 18, daughter of Daniel & Mary VanAllen
VanAllen Mary 1844 Jul 29 D ae 6/8/17, daughter of George W. & Susan VanAllen
VanAllen Susan Ann 1842 Mar 21 D ae 1/5/26, daughter of Wm B. & Charity VanAllen
VanAllen Sylvester # 1852 B1836
Walling Martha H[elen Shannon] 1902 B1828, wife of Tewalt Walling [died age 74/3/20, daughter of Noadiah & Sarah Little Shannon]
Walling Tewalt 1907 B1828
Webster Nellie M. 1915 B1874 [wife of William Webster]
Webster William 1946 B1868
Wilkin Sarah A. 1831 Aug 15 D ae 20/10/2; wife of Wm R. Wilkin

For help with abbreviations and conventions, click here.